Income Alternatives in a Zero Interest Rate World
The State of Interest Rates
News lows, new landscape.
Interest rates in most of the developed world are at historical lows1 with the yield on traditional income producing assets like bonds also at lows not seen in decades2. This presents a challenge for investors who now need to look for alternative ways to generate income. This can be especially important for those investors who rely on the income from these investments to fund their retirement.
Why are Interest Rates so Low?
Kickstarting and curbing growth.
Interest rates are a tool used by the U.S. Federal Reserve (the Fed) to either kick-start or curb growth within the economy. As expressed in the graph above, when growth is low the Fed will has historically reduced interest rates, making it cheaper to borrow which is intended to cause businesses to invest, which creates jobs, which increases the wealth of employees who then consume more. The reverse is true. When growth is too high, inflationary pressures generally reduce purchasing power. To combat this, the Fed has historically increased rates, making borrowing more expensive thereby dampening economic growth and encouraging savings. Over a full economic cycle, the Fed has sought to use rates to maintain an equilibrium between growth, employment and inflation3.
In history, the Fed has only reduced interest rates to the zero-rate bound (targeting 0 to 0.25%) twice. The first time was in response to the 2008 Global Financial Crisis, where rates remained at this level for 7 years4. The second time was in March 2020 in response to the severe economic shock resulting from the COVID-19 pandemic. As in the past, the Fed will use low interest rates to help restart the economy. A potential problem however is that the Fed rate acts as an anchor, effectively weighing down all other market interest rates. This can leave investors seeking alternative options to replace lost yield.
Identifying Alternative Sources of Income
A bonded interest.
When investors think about income, they traditionally think of bonds and they have come accustomed to utilizing them for income. Since the peak of the last interest rate cycle in 1981, bonds have paid out on average 5.7%5, conditioning investors to expect a yield around this level. In addition, bonds are considered to be a relatively safe investment on account of the fact that bond holders are considered creditors to the company that ‘borrows’ their funds and generally rank higher in terms of claims on a company assets should they go into bankruptcy. However, the current interest rate on the U.S. 10-Year Treasury is just 1.9%, well below its average and the expectations of investors. This is a significant income shortfall.
Looking at other traditional income sources, the U.S. High Yield Bond is generating just 5.2%. This higher yield reflects the compensation for the higher risk of these bonds which are considered non-investment grade, or junk bonds6. Shifting to equities, investors have historically averaged a 2.1% dividend yield on the S&P 500 since 19907 and at a higher level of overall risk. Both of these options may involve a tradeoff for the investor. Either increase risk to achieve a similar level of income in the case of the high yield bond, or reduce the desired income in favor of an increase total return while at the same time increasing exposure to the risk of stocks. By looking more broadly to alternative sources of income however, investors can potentially access some attractive income streams that have the benefit of diversification.
Looking beyond bonds.
Today, real estate, infrastructure and direct lending all deliver more income than investment grade bonds. Rather than the income received being generated solely from the interest payments from the underlying company, which rely on those companies generating profits, they can be derived from rental payments on real estate, or tolls and fees associated with infrastructure.
An additional benefit that these investments have is that they are all lowly correlated with global bonds themselves8. This means that they are less sensitive to the movements in the price of bonds thereby diversifying some of the risk associated with a traditional portfolio that includes just stocks and bonds.
By simply casting a wider net for alternative sources of income, investors may supplement the lost income of traditional bonds, while diversifying their portfolio.